Match Ratings

Rating wrestling matches with a star rating out of five (or more) is something fans have been doing since time immemorial.

The person most regarded for doing this is Dave Meltzer. The Wrestling Observer founder has been giving matches ratings since the 1980s, and shows no signs of stopping.

However, if you’d rather a different view, Cagematch.net is the largest site where fans can vote on match ratings. This shows a diverse range of opinions, and any match over the 9.00 is one you know is worth a watch.

In addition, here at Atletifo, we also like to give our two cents about various matches, promos and segments from throughout the world of wrestling.

In this page, we’ll detail the match ratings for a variety of matches and events from the world of wrestling. These will be separated by wrestling company, and you can click the company name to see even more star ratings for their shows!

wWE Star Ratings

dave meltzer 5 star WWE matches

Every 5 Star Match in WWE History (According To Dave Meltzer)

One of the most polarising things wrestling fans argue about is Dave Meltzer‘s five-star WWE match list. The Wrestling Observer journalist has been covering wrestling in his weekly newsletter since … Read more

Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings For Survivor Series 2022 (And Other Match Ratings)

WWE Survivor Series 2023 took place in Chicago, Illinois, which is the home of great wrestlers like CM Punk and Bobby Heenan. The event marked the second annual War Games … Read more

WWE Star Ratings For Every PLE In 2023

This page will be your source for Dave Meltzer’s star ratings for every single WWE Premium Live Event in 2023. The ratings are taken from editions of the Wrestling Observer, … Read more

Crown Jewel 2023 Meltzer’s Star Ratings Revealed (Roman Reigns vs LA Knight)

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 is the latest in the WWE’s offering from Saudi Arabia, and looks to be the most star-studded event since the inaugural “Greatest Royal Rumble” event. While … Read more

Check out more WWE Star Ratings by clicking this link!

AEW Star Ratings

Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings for AEW X NJPW Forbidden Door 2024

Dave Meltzer has given his star ratings for AEW x NJPW’s Forbidden Door 2024. This year’s edition also featured stars from Stardom and CMLL, making it one of the biggest … Read more
AEW Five Star Matches

Every 5 Star Match in AEW History Rated By Dave Meltzer

Putting on great matches is what wrestling is all about. People want to pay money to see their favourites wrestling great matches, and the better a match is, the more … Read more

Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings For Survivor Series 2022 (And Other Match Ratings)

WWE Survivor Series 2023 took place in Chicago, Illinois, which is the home of great wrestlers like CM Punk and Bobby Heenan. The event marked the second annual War Games … Read more

AEW Full Gear 2023 Meltzer’s Star Ratings Revealed (Winners & Losers)

The fifth-annual AEW Full Gear event is taking place in 2023, and it is looking like one of the best cards AEW have put on so far. Adam Copeland, who … Read more

Check out more WWE Star Ratings by clicking this link!

NJPW Star Ratings

Wrestle Kingdom 5 Star Ratings (Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings)

Wrestle Kingdom 5 was one of the most international-feeling events in the history of the show, with superstars from NJPW, TNA and CMLL in Mexico taking place at the event. … Read more

Wrestle Kingdom 4 Star Ratings (Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings)

Wrestle Kingdom 4 took place on January 4, 2010 in the Tokyo Dome. 41,500 fans attended the show, although NJPW only claimed 20,000 fans attended the show. This is one … Read more

Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings For Survivor Series 2022 (And Other Match Ratings)

WWE Survivor Series 2023 took place in Chicago, Illinois, which is the home of great wrestlers like CM Punk and Bobby Heenan. The event marked the second annual War Games … Read more

Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings For Every Wrestle Kingdom Show (NJPW)

Wrestle Kingdom is NJPW’s yearly wrestling event, taking place on the 4th January every year. It takes place in the Tokyo Dome in Tokyo, Japan, and the event follows on … Read more

Check out more NJPW Star Ratings by clicking this link!

You can also check out the match ratings from some of the biggest shows ever! Click the links to see every star rating, match rating and our view on the following events:

Five-Star Matches

Five stars is generally seen as the top ranking one can give. Whether it’s a fantastic movie, a brilliant album or a top-notch video game, if it’s five stars, you have to experience it.

Wrestling is no different. Fans and critics alike have always given their views, with stars their preferred currency. While Dave Meltzer has broken his five-star scale multiple times now, a match at that rating is generally considered a must match.

If you want to find out about some of the five-star matches you should watch, then you are in luck. Click any of the links that below that tickle your fancy to learn about some of the best matches in wrestling history.

info

PH +1 000 000 0000

24 M Drive
East Hampton, NY 11937

© 2024 INFO

PRIVACY POLICY terms of service

Privacy Policy