Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings For NXT No Mercy 2023

The match ratings for NXT No Mercy 2023 are in, and there are some very interesting matches took place at the show – but were there any five-star matches?

WWE produced the No Mercy 2023 this year, taking pace on October 1, 2023. This was the latest NXT exclusive PLE, with head booker Shawn Michaels putting on one of the best NXT shows we’ve seen so far under his reign.

No Mercy is the first WWE Premium Live Event to be produced under the “TKO” banner, ever since the company merged with the UFC to create this new fighting megacorp. While no UFC fighters are expected to appear on the show, we cannot rule out any surprise appearances in NXT.

WWE even referenced the classic “WWF No Mercy” video game for the Nintendo 64 in their promo video for the show – click below to watch that video right now!

NXT No Mercy 2023 has seven matches booked on the show, with some of the top stars in NXT taking part. This includes NXT Champion Carmelo Hayes, Bron Breakker, NXT Women’s Champion Becky Lynch and many, many more.

In this article, we’ll detail all the star ratings for the matches at NXT No Mercy 2023. This includes our own personal ratings for the match, the user rating from the aggregate site, Cagematch.net, and Dave Meltzer’s star ratings from the Wrestling Observer.

NXT No Mercy 2023 Star Ratings

Here are all of the match ratings and star ratings for NXT No Mercy 2023. This includes for matches like Becky Lynch vs Tiffany Stratton, Dominik Mysterio vs Trick Williams and Bron Breakker vs Baron Corbin.

Let us know your personal star ratings for the matches at No Mercy 2023 in the comments section below.

Pre Show: Blair Davenport vs Kelani Jordan

• Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings – 1.5 Stars
• Cagematch Rating – 6.30
• Atletifo Match Rating – 2 Stars

Bron Breakker vs Baron Corbin

Baron Corbin defeated Bron Breakker with the “End of Days”, after Robert Stone distracted Breakker.

• Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings – 2.75 Stars
• Cagematch Rating – 6.73
• Atletifo Match Rating – 3 Stars

Dominik Mysterio vs Trick Williams

Just two years after he began wrestling training, Trick Williams pinned Judgement Day’s Dominik Mysterio win the NXT North American Championship.

• Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings – 2.5 Stars
• Cagematch Rating – 6.17
• Atletifo Match Rating – 2 Stars

The Family vs OTM vs Creed Brothers vs Humberto Carillo & Angel Garza (NXT Tag Team Championships)

The Family won this four-way tag team title match, retaining their NXT Tag Team Championships.

• Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings – 3.75 Stars
• Cagematch Rating – 7.57
• Atletifo Match Rating – 3 Stars

Noam Dar vs Butch (NXT Heritage Cup)

Noam Dar won the UK Heritage Cup, pinning Pete Dunne in the sixth round to win the match 2-1.

• Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings – 3.25 Stars
• Cagematch Rating – 6.98
• Atletifo Match Rating – 1.5 Stars

Carmelo Hayes vs Ilja Dragunov (NXT Championship)

Ilja Dragunov became the first former-NXT UK Champion to win the NXT Championship, pinning Carmelo Hayes to win the NXT title for the first time.

• Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings – 4.75 Stars
• Cagematch Rating – 9.37
• Atletifo Match Rating – 4 Stars

Becky Lynch vs Tiffany Stratton (NXT Women’s Championship)

In an Extreme Rules match, Becky Lynch defeated Tiffany Stratton to retain her NXT Championship.

• Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings – 4.5 Stars
• Cagematch Rating – 8.70
• Atletifo Match Rating – 3.5 Stars