Skip to Content

What Happened to Marty Scurll? Speaking Out, AEW and Return to Wrestling

What Happened to Marty Scurll? Speaking Out, AEW and Return to Wrestling

Many fans of NJPW or early Being The Elite may be wondering what happened to Marty Scurll? The Villain of Bullet Club was one of the biggest and baddest up and coming stars in wrestling around the time The Elite were becoming the biggest thing in wrestling since the NWO.

The English star was one of the premier talents of the group. Ranked up there alongside WWE’s Cody Rhodes and former AEW Champion Adam Page, Marty Scurll seemed destined for greatness.

He has not been seen on TV in years and an inevitable deal with AEW seems to have gone up in smoke in a matter of moments. So, what happened to Marty Scurll? Is Marty Scurll in AEW? And will The Villain return to wrestling any time soon?

What happened to Marty Scurll?

Marty Scurll was fired from his role of ROH booker and kicked out of The Elite after being accused of sexual assault during the Speaking Out movement in wrestling in 2020.

He was accused by a former pupil of his, a 16 year old aspiring wrestler who went by @mystickttn on Twitter. The British woman wrote on her Twitter account on June 22nd, 2020 that she was fed drinks by IPW’s Dan Elder all night, getting her drunk despite being under the drinking age in public.

This took place at an IPW after party, the victim claims. She went on to write that she met Marty Scurll outside the party venue, where he tried to convince her to have sex with him back at her hotel. saying “”we should go back together, let’s go back to the hotel, let’s f**k.”.

She claimed she tried to politely exit the conversation by claiming her friend had the key to her hotel room. However, she later went to retrieve the room key from said friend, despite being warned that going back with Scurll was a bad idea. She was refused the key and set off with Marty Scurll anyway “without the key”.

He walked her back to her hotel room, despite neither having access to the room. They made their way to the “independent, small hotel” and sat outside her room, unable to gain entry. Here, she claims, Marty Scurll “sat on a chair and got his penis out and told me to suck it. So I did.”. Given the fact that she was only 16 and Scurll was in his early thirties, and that she had been plied with drinks all night, makes this encounter as disturbing as it is shocking.

Marty Scurll and ROH parted ways after the allegations against him became public

He then propositioned her to have unprotected sex and reportedly tried “to stick his unprotected penis inside me”, despite the victims repeated claims of “I’m so sorry, I’m still a virgin”. However, Scurll seemed determined and would not take no for an answer, despite his 16 year old victim not wanting to and being in no frame of mind to consent to the awful act he was about to commit.

Luckily, her friend showed up soon after and told Marty Scurll to leave. Luckily she avoided even more trauma, although in the same breathe she did reveal she had previously been raped by Dan Edler, the man who had been feeder her drinks all night before the encounter with Marty Scurll.

The Villain (the apt nickname Scurll chose for himself inside the Bullet Club) did issue a statement revealing his side of the events, but it was too little too late. He had become a pariah in wrestling, unbookable by the top promotions and his once-promising career now in tatters.

He lost his reported $700k a year job as the head booker for Ring of Honor, as well as any hope of signing for WWE or AEW in the future. He was also not booked again by Ring of Honor, with his sole appearance on New Japan Strong never aired after the allegations became public.

The full accusation of what happened to Marty Scurll and his victim can be read here. What happened between Marty Scurll and his victim are abhorrent and should be read only at your own risk.

Marty Scurll to AEW?

As a long-time friend of The Elite, Marty Scurll seemed certain to join AEW once his ROH contract expired in 2020. His deal ran out after his teammates in Bullet Club and was expected to join his friends in AEW once his deal was up.

However he shocked the world. Instead of Marty Scurll signing with AEW, he signed a new deal with Ring of Honor. Worth a reported $700k a year, Scurll was made head booker of ROH and given a premier spot at the top of the company.

It was an offer AEW and WWE simply could not match and was a no-brainer for The Villain. He signed the multi-year deal, although that did no preclude future dealings with AEW. It was thought likely that he would link up with The Elite in an inter-promotional storyline, as AEW have done before with Impact Wrestling and New Japan Pro Wrestling.

However, before that could happen his alleged crimes came out and Marty Scurll’s AEW dreams were in tatters. However, he did not stay out of wrestling for long…

Return to Wrestling

Marty Scurll has returned to wrestling since being fired by Ring of Honor. However, he has only found success on small, regional shows and some of them have received backlash for booking The Villain to wrestle in their promotions. This had led to him making Puerto Rico a “home from home” and wrestles regularly in the promotion.

He was recently booked to appear at former WWE Superstar Santino Marella’s promotion Battle Arts. He was announced by Marella on Twitter, but the announcement has received much backlash from fans who remember the allegations against Marty Scurll in 2020.

https://twitter.com/milanmiracle/status/1546514510286127108

Marty Scurll also has his own Vlog on Youtube, attempting to mirror the success he once had as part of the Being the Elite web series. His channel currently has over 20,000 subscribers and chronicles his journey in wrestling since being fired for sexual assault allegations.

Why Didn’t Marty Scurll Join AEW?

Whilst he seemed to be a shoe-in to join AEW since the beginning, there were a variety of reasons why the former ROH and NJPW wrestler did not join AEW.

The first reason Marty Scurll didn’t join AEW was simply because of the timing. Whilst the rest of The Elite all ran out of their NJPW contracts on January 4th, 2019, Scurll was a little different. He was instead signed full time to ROH who had a different structure for their deals. His contract therefore ran out the year after, meaning he would have to wait for AEW to form before he could make his long-awaited debut.

Being a huge part of the group and a main star on Being the Elite, few envision Marty Scurll not joining AEW. He was heavily rumoured to be the leader of The Dark Order before Brodie Lee ultimately snagged the role of The Exalted One. Instead of signing for AEW, he was offered a “too good to be true” deal from Ring of Honor, granting him a 7 figure salary and, most importantly, booking powers.

He was given the creative reigns for the company which was something too good to turn down. Instead of joining his friend in AEW he instead took over at ROH and tried to book the company out of despair and bring them from the bring. However, he failed to do so due to being fired for the allegations detailed above.

Those allegations are the third and final reason why Marty Scurll didn’t join AEW and while he will never set foot in the company. They wont touch him with a barge pole and he is damaged goods. No-one in their right mind will pay to see him and he has ruined his incredibly promising career before it really took off.

What do you think of Marty Scurll? Why do you think he didn’t sign for AEW? Tell us what you think in the comments or click below to read about CM Punk vs MJF

John

Sunday 23rd of October 2022

I don't agree with what he did, but it seems odd that she would go out for drinks with someone that previously raped her.(Edler)

Cindy Khan

Tuesday 12th of July 2022

Oh I really should check that vlog out!